In a surprising twist at the American Music Awards, global superstar Beyoncé took home the Favorite Female Country Artist award—beating out respected country talents Lainey Wilson, Kacey Musgraves, Ella Langley, and Megan Moroney.

While the pop and R&B icon has recently explored country influences in her music, many longtime fans of the genre were left stunned by the decision.

Public Reaction to Beyoncé’s Country Music Win

After the results were announced, fans took to social media in droves to express their confusion and frustration. It didn’t go unnoticed that Beyoncé did not win in the all-genre category—but managed to secure a win specifically in country music, a genre she’s still relatively new to.

Here’s what some listeners had to say on social platforms:

• “Well that award was definitely paid for by her husband.”

• “She got one thing right… this ain’t Texas.”

• “Absolute joke! Lainey and Ella run circles around her!”

• “She ain’t country!”

• “They should show proof of this win, because that’s a joke! Favorite country, when 99% of country fans won’t listen to her.”

• “Funny, I have not met anyone who says they even like a song—much less the whole album.”

Is Beyoncé’s Move Into Country Music Authentic?

While Beyoncé’s country-inspired project has received praise from some music critics, die-hard country fans continue to question the authenticity and fairness behind such award wins. As debates continue, one thing is certain: her foray into country is stirring up major conversations in both the music industry and fan circles.